A New York state judge has dismissed New York City’s lawsuit accusing Exxon Mobil, BP, Shell, and the American Petroleum Institute of misleading the public about fossil fuels and their commitment to clean energy.
Justice Anar Patel ruled the city could not argue its environmentally aware residents were duped by the companies’ alleged failure to disclose the climate impact of their products. “The city cannot have it both ways,” Patel wrote.
The judge found no evidence the companies engaged in “greenwashing” or ran deceptive campaigns to boost fossil fuel sales. Statements like Exxon’s claim that its fuel helps people drive “cleaner, smarter, and longer” were deemed too vague to imply dishonesty.
New York City argued the companies falsely portrayed themselves as climate leaders while making minimal investments in renewable energy. The city sought civil fines and an end to these practices.
Nicholas Paolucci, a spokesperson for the city’s law department, said the city is reviewing its options. “Our complaint alleged these defendants misled consumers about their role in a clean energy future. Companies violating consumer protection laws must be held accountable.”
Exxon rejected the claims, saying: “Ideological hatred doesn’t mean we did anything wrong.” Shell declined to comment, and BP did not respond.
The decision comes as other U.S. cities and states pursue similar lawsuits. Patel’s ruling followed the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to let Honolulu proceed with its lawsuit against major oil companies.
The American Petroleum Institute praised the dismissal, stating, “Climate policy belongs in Congress, not the courts.”
The case is City of New York v. Exxon Mobil Corp et al, New York State Supreme Court, No. 451071/2021.
Also read: Yellen Defends COVID Stimulus, Highlights Economic Growth
